Previous work on aneurysm wall motion
| Authors and Year of Publication | Imaging Modality | Study Object | No. | Aneurysms and Rupture Status | Frequency of Wall Motion Detection | Wall Motion Quantification |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wardlaw and Cannon (1996)14 | PD-US | In vivo | 40 | 6U/31R | Not reported | Yes |
| Wardlaw et al (1998)15 | PD-US | In vivo | 9 | 3U/9R | Not reported | Yes |
| Hoskins et al (1998)16 | PD-US | Phantom | NA | NA | NA | Yes |
| Kato et al (2004)17 | 4D-CTA | In vivo | 15 | 15U | 10/15a | No |
| Hayakawa et al (2005)18 | 4D-CTA | In vivo | 23 | 23R | 4/23 | No |
| Ishida et al (2005)19 | 4D-CTA | In vivo | 30 | 29U/5R | 13/34 | No |
| Yaghmai et al (2007)20 | 4D-CTA | Phantom | NA | NA | NA | No |
| Krings et al (2009)21 | 4D-CTA | In vivo | 1 | 1U | 1/1 | Yes |
| Hayakawa et al (2011)22 | 4D-CTA | In vivo | 51 | 53U/12R | 24/65 | No |
| Kuroda et al (2012)23 | 4D-CTA | In vivo | 18 | 22U | Not reported | Yes |
| Firouzian et al (2013)24 | 4D-CTA | In vivo | 14 | 19U | 19/19 | Yes |
| Hayakawa et al (2014)25 | 4D-CTA | In vivo | 37 | 56U | 20/56 | No |
| Meyer et al (1993)26 | PC-MRA | In vivo | 15 | 10U/6R | 15/16 | Yes |
| Karmonik et al (2010)27 | PC-MRA | In vivo | 7 | 7U | 7/7 | Yes |
| Dempere-Marco et al (2006)28 | 3D RA | In vivo | 3 | 3U | 2/3 | Yes |
| Oubel et al (2007)29 | 3D RA | In vivo | 4 | 4U | 4/4 | Yes |
| Zhang et al (2009)30 | 3D RA | Phantom | NA | NA | NA | Yes |
| Zhang et al (2009)31 | 3D RA | Phantom | NA | NA | NA | Yes |
| Oubel et al (2010)32 | 3D RA | In vivo | 18 | 11U/7R | 10/18 | Yes |
| Zhang et al (2011)33 | 3D RA | Phantom + in vivo | 2 | 2U | 1/2 | Yes |
Note:—No. indicates number of patients; PD-US, power Doppler ultrasonography; PC-MRA, phase-contrast MR angiography; 3D RA, 3D rotational angiography; U, unruptured; R, ruptured; NA, not applicable.
↵a Authors focused on bleb detection only. Pulsating bleb was found in 10 of the 15 cases.